Back to Blog

SEO

How to choose an SEO agency: questions to ask and red flags

Admin User
How to choose an SEO agency: questions to ask and red flags

We're writing this as an SEO agency, so the conflict of interest is plain. That's why we rely on the guidance Google has published rather than our own word. Here's what to know before turning to an agency or consultant.

First: do you really need an SEO expert?

Google's "Do you need an SEO expert?" page is an honest starting point: some businesses can do the basics themselves. But if your site's structure is complex, you're short on time, or you're taking on something risky like a site migration, expert help makes sense. To get a sense of things, read Google's SEO starter guide, or look at your site's state with our free SEO analysis.

What nobody can guarantee

Google's warning is clear: no one can guarantee the #1 position on Google. Be wary of anyone who says:

  • "Guaranteed #1" or "definite first page,"
  • "We have a special relationship with Google,"
  • "We'll submit your site to Google with priority" (no such service exists),
  • Mass emails from an address you don't know claiming they've "analyzed" your site,
  • Buying links or link networks for quick results. This violates Google's spam policies and can harm your site.

The responsibility is yours, too: as Google notes, you're responsible for whom you hire. A spam method an agency applies can damage your site's visibility.

Questions to ask in the first meeting

  1. What work have you done in my industry / for companies of similar size? Ask for references and case studies, but hear any claimed results in context.
  2. What will you do in the first 90 days? A clear work plan: technical audit, keyword / content plan, internal linking, measurement setup.
  3. How will we measure success? Not just "rankings": organic sessions, qualified forms, sales. For measurement setup see the GA4 guide.
  4. Who will make changes on the site? What access do you need?
  5. Which methods do you not use? Clearly rejecting things like link buying, mass AI content and fake reviews is a good sign.
  6. What will reporting look like? How often, with which metrics, in plain language?
  7. Contract and exit terms? Who owns the data, accounts and content? Do you keep access if you leave?

Good signs

  • They take time to understand your business and your customer,
  • They present results as "targets and forecasts," not "guarantees,"
  • They show technical foundations (technical audit) and content gaps first,
  • They're transparent: they explain what they do and why,
  • They say honestly that SEO takes time. On a new site or in a competitive space, results can take months.

On price

The cheapest offer is usually the one with the least effort in it; the most expensive is not a guarantee of quality either. Weigh price together with scope: how much content, how much technical work, how much reporting. Also match budget to expectations; expecting fast results on a competitive keyword with a small budget isn't realistic.

We describe how we work on our SEO service page; don't hesitate to ask us the same questions you'd ask any agency: contact.

Sources

How to Choose an SEO Agency: Questions and Red Flags | Auryn Dijital